Payhip vs Sellfy
Payhip and Sellfy are two of the most popular all-in-one storefronts for selling digital products, and they price it in opposite ways. Payhip offers a free plan with a per-sale fee that shrinks on paid tiers, while Sellfy charges a flat monthly plan with no transaction cut. They also diverge on features: Payhip leans into courses and memberships, Sellfy into print-on-demand merch.
Quick answer
Choose Payhip if you want to start truly free and add courses or memberships, accepting a per-sale fee until you upgrade; choose Sellfy if you sell steadily and prefer a flat monthly plan with no per-sale cut, plus print-on-demand merch. Both are solid, so compare their current pricing against your volume. If you'd rather pay no platform cut and no monthly fee, OneSol is a free all-in-one alternative that pays straight into your own Stripe and keeps 100% of your sales.
Payhip vs Sellfy at a glance
| Feature | Payhip | Sellfy |
|---|---|---|
| Free to start | Free plan | Free trial |
| Pricing model | Free + paid tiers | Monthly plan |
| Cut on sales | Fee on free (lower paid) | 0% (pay monthly) |
| Digital products | Yes | Yes |
| Courses & memberships | Courses + memberships | Subscriptions |
| Print-on-demand merch | No | Yes |
| Email marketing | Built-in | Built-in |
| Ease of use | Easy | Easy |
Competitor features and pricing can change — check their current plans before deciding.
1. Where Payhip fits best
Payhip is the safer start for anyone testing the waters, because its free plan lets you sell without a monthly bill and its course and membership tools are strong. The trade-off is a per-sale fee on the free tier, which you reduce by moving up to a paid plan as you grow.
2. Where Sellfy fits best
Sellfy fits creators selling consistently enough that a flat monthly plan with no per-sale cut pays off, and those who want print-on-demand merch alongside digital goods. It trades the free-forever option for predictable pricing and a more retail-style storefront.
3. The cost that's easy to miss
These two swap where the cost hides. Payhip looks free but skims each sale until you upgrade; Sellfy looks pricier monthly but takes nothing per sale. Run your expected volume through both models — the winner flips depending on how much you actually sell.
The verdict
OneSol is the free all-in-one option that sits outside the Payhip-vs-Sellfy fee debate entirely: from one link you sell products, run forms, take bookings and capture emails, with payments going straight into your own Stripe. There's no platform cut and no monthly plan to justify, so you keep 100% of every sale minus only Stripe's standard fee.
FAQ
Which is cheaper, Payhip or Sellfy?
Low or irregular sellers usually save with Payhip's free plan; steady, higher-volume sellers often come out ahead on Sellfy's flat monthly plan since it takes no per-sale cut. Check current pricing against your numbers.
Can both sell courses and memberships?
Payhip has dedicated course and membership features, while Sellfy supports subscriptions. If structured courses are central to your business, Payhip is generally the stronger option.
Does either offer print-on-demand merch?
Sellfy includes print-on-demand for branded merch; Payhip focuses on digital products, courses and coupons. Choose Sellfy if physical merch is part of your plan.
Is there a free alternative that keeps 100% of sales?
Yes — OneSol is free with no platform cut and pays into your own Stripe, so you keep 100% minus only Stripe's standard fee, plus forms, bookings and email capture from one link.